Angostura Bitters
This page may contain affiliate links. If you buy through them, Educated Ice™ earns a small commission at no extra cost (and likely a savings) to you. I only recommend bottles and gear I would actually use. Full disclosure.
The Cheapest Bottle Doing the Most Work
Ten dollars, lasts a year, no substitute really substitutes. The final Foundation Six edition: a battlefield surgeon's stomach remedy, the label that is famously too big for its bottle, and the oldest celebration drink in the American canon.
From Army Medicine to Every Bar on Earth
In 1824 a German doctor named Johann Siegert, serving as surgeon general in Simon Bolivar's army, perfected a bitter herbal tonic in the Venezuelan town of Angostura. Stomach medicine first, cocktail legend later. His sons moved production to Port of Spain, Trinidad, in 1875, and it is still made there today.
Two things everyone gets wrong. First, the name is the town, not the plant - there is no angostura bark in Angostura bitters, whatever the copycats imply; the backbone is gentian root and a secret bill of herbs and spices. Second, the alcohol: it is carried at a bracing 44.7 percent, which sounds alarming until you remember it is used two dashes at a time. Nobody is drinking bitters. Bitters are seasoning - the salt and pepper of the bar.
As for that label, comically oversized for its bottle: the story bartenders tell is that it was a mistake between two brothers, one ordering bottles and the other labels, kept because people noticed it. The company has never seemed in a hurry to confirm the details, and frankly the label is doing fine either way.
Usually $8 to $12 for the standard bottle, and it outlives every other purchase on this list. If your bar owns exactly one bottle of bitters, it is this one, and it is not close.
Angostura Aromatic Bitters - usually $8 to $12 a bottle at the store; on Amazon the sane buy is the ~$19 two-pack, and the spare disappears into a gift kit sooner or later. It has a row on The Complete List too.
The smallest bottle on the bar does the most work.
The Champagne Cocktail
Jerry Thomas put this in the first American bar manual in 1862. It is older than the Manhattan, easier than everything, and it makes inexpensive sparkling wine taste like a decision instead of a compromise.
The Champagne Cocktail
- 1 sugar cube
- 3-4 dashes Angostura bitters
- 1/4 oz cognac (optional)
- About 5 oz chilled Champagne or dry sparkling wine, to top
- Lemon peel
Soak the sugar cube with the bitters, drop it in a flute, add the cognac if you are feeling generous, top slowly with the sparkling wine, express the lemon peel over the rim.
Watch the cube fizz from the bottom of the flute. Cheap theater, excellent drink.
What Bitters Actually Do
Think of bitters the way a cook thinks of salt. Salt does not make food salty when it is used right - it makes food taste more like itself. Two dashes of Angostura do the same for a drink: they knit the sweet and the strong together, add a baseline of spice the tongue reads as depth, and cut the cloying edge off sugar. That is why the Old Fashioned recipe is two hundred years old and three ingredients long - whiskey, sugar, bitters is the entire original definition of the word cocktail.
The test is easy to run at home. Make two Old Fashioneds, one with bitters and one without. The one without tastes like sweetened whiskey. The one with tastes finished. Ten dollars rarely teaches a clearer lesson.
That closes the Foundation Six - the six bottles, about $130 all in, that make a dozen classics on day one. The newsletter covers bottles the way the site does: one honest pour at a time, every month.
Worth Your Click
Where to go deeper on the site this edition:
- The whole starter bar these six editions walked through: The Well.
- Getting the flagship bitters drink exactly right: The Perfect Old Fashioned.
- Drinks for occasions, sparkling and otherwise: Seasonal & Occasion Cocktails.
- Or ask the Cocktail Builder what your shelf can already make.
The ice remembers...
- H. Finch